Projectile Turret - 2007/09/07 22:23"At the beginning of battle, Projectile Turret may deal 1 damage to any number of attacking ships. If Projectile Turret deals damage to more than two ships at once, it is destroyed."
Can it be used during any battle, being in any region? Being between two other people if playing multiplayer?
The administrator has disabled public write access.
RedX
User Cruiser
Posts: 130
Re:Projectile Turret - 2007/09/08 06:13Oh, my... they really have gone a bit far on this one. As written, it can peg any attacking force anywhere, as opposed to simply those in your home region.
Neat... and something I expect to see in the Errata.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Ryuteki
User Battlecruiser
Posts: 679
Re:Projectile Turret - 2007/09/08 07:31RedX wrote: Oh, my... they really have gone a bit far on this one. As written, it can peg any attacking force anywhere, as opposed to simply those in your home region.
Neat... and something I expect to see in the Errata.
Negative, sorry. The meta-rule is, anything that triggers off of "attack" or "battle" must be present in the battle, and if it targets, must target cards in that battle.-Ryuteki, Owner of the Rules! We're playing Monday evenings in IL, see www.games-plus.com for the address or email me at ryuteki AT gmail DOT com.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
RedX
User Cruiser
Posts: 130
Re:Projectile Turret - 2007/09/08 18:26Ryuteki wrote: RedX wrote: Oh, my... they really have gone a bit far on this one. As written, it can peg any attacking force anywhere, as opposed to simply those in your home region.
Neat... and something I expect to see in the Errata.
Negative, sorry. The meta-rule is, anything that triggers off of "attack" or "battle" must be present in the battle, and if it targets, must target cards in that battle.
Eh? Ah, so that's what keeps Serpentis Drug Outlet under control! Thanks.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Kempeth
User Battlecruiser
Posts: 367
Re:Projectile Turret - 2008/06/30 07:46Ryuteki wrote: RedX wrote: Oh, my... they really have gone a bit far on this one. As written, it can peg any attacking force anywhere, as opposed to simply those in your home region.
Neat... and something I expect to see in the Errata.
Negative, sorry. The meta-rule is, anything that triggers off of "attack" or "battle" must be present in the battle, and if it targets, must target cards in that battle.I'd be interested to know where that "meta-rule" comes from? I've never seen anything like that...
Any other such card I can recall specifically says "in this region". I'm not saying it should work as implied by the cardtext. That would be unrealistic and overpowered.
I'm bringin this up because I'm considering to change this text for my new octgn patch...
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Brootal
User Battlecruiser
Posts: 485
Re:Projectile Turret - 2008/07/01 00:31dredging up old posts to keep some activity on the board?
Somewhere around the same time as this post (roughly) I'm sure there was a discussion of this in another card (possibly a serpentis drug outlet) and I think it came back to a ruling by one of the games designers at a major event.
Yes is should be published somewhere, but like a lot of things it never was.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Kempeth
User Battlecruiser
Posts: 367
Re:Projectile Turret - 2008/07/01 06:04Brootal wrote: dredging up old posts to keep some activity on the board?
Somewhere around the same time as this post (roughly) I'm sure there was a discussion of this in another card (possibly a serpentis drug outlet) and I think it came back to a ruling by one of the games designers at a major event.
Yes is should be published somewhere, but like a lot of things it never was. Nope I simply stumbled over this issue myself and wasn't able to find the referenced rule. It makes sense though but it was just hanging there like "[citation needed]" in wikipedia...
It makes sense but I'll probably still gonna change the text. I find that better because it decreases the size of the mental rule catalog.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
Ryuteki
User Battlecruiser
Posts: 679
Re:Projectile Turret - 2008/08/04 04:34Kempeth wrote: Brootal wrote: dredging up old posts to keep some activity on the board?
Somewhere around the same time as this post (roughly) I'm sure there was a discussion of this in another card (possibly a serpentis drug outlet) and I think it came back to a ruling by one of the games designers at a major event.
Yes is should be published somewhere, but like a lot of things it never was. Nope I simply stumbled over this issue myself and wasn't able to find the referenced rule. It makes sense though but it was just hanging there like "[citation needed]" in wikipedia...
It makes sense but I'll probably still gonna change the text. I find that better because it decreases the size of the mental rule catalog.
IIRC it was a designer meta-ruling made at the GenCon 2007 Championships. I suppose it's slightly possible it was a designer meta-ruling from playtest though - my memory fades for such things.-Ryuteki, Owner of the Rules! We're playing Monday evenings in IL, see www.games-plus.com for the address or email me at ryuteki AT gmail DOT com.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
